The Mother's Day Murder

  Please turn to the back of the book for a conversation between Lee Harris and Christine Bennett

  I could not exaggerate the shock I experienced at hearing her pronouncement. For a moment it left me short of breath and dizzy. I’m not sure whether there was a fleeting moment in which I thought that what she said might be true or whether I simply felt immediate disgust and anger that anyone would say something so untrue, so impossible to believe, and so impossible to have happened—something that could devastate the life and career of a woman whom I believed to be a paragon of virtue.

  “Tina,” I said, “I think you should reconsider what you just said. I’ve known Sister Joseph for most of my life. She is a devout Catholic, a devoted member of the convent, a great leader. She has never had a child.”

  “Were you there twenty years ago?”

  By Lee Harris

  Published by Fawcett Books:

  THE GOOD FRIDAY MURDER

  THE YOM KIPPUR MURDER

  THE CHRISTENING DAY MURDER

  THE ST. PATRICK’S DAY MURDER

  THE CHRISTMAS NIGHT MURDER

  THE THANKSGIVING DAY MURDER

  THE PASSOVER MURDER

  THE VALENTINE’S DAY MURDER

  THE NEW YEAR’S EVE MURDER

  THE LABOR DAY MURDER

  THE FATHER’S DAY MURDER

  THE MOTHER’S DAY MURDER

  THE APRIL FOOLS’ DAY MURDER

  THE HAPPY BIRTHDAY MURDER

  A Fawcett Book

  Published by The Ballantine Publishing Group

  Copyright © 2000 by Lee Harris

  All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. Published in the United States by The Ballantine Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc., New York, and simultaneously in Canada by Random House of Canada Limited, Toronto.

  Fawcett and colophon are trademarks of Random House, Inc.

  www.ballantinebooks.com

  Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 00-190071

  eISBN: 978-0-307-80346-7

  v3.1

  To my daughter, Molly,

  who makes being a mother a pleasure

  every day of the year

  The author wishes to thank Ana M. Soler and James L. V. Wegman for a happy dozen books of help and information, which just get better all the time!

  Oh, my son’s my son till he gets him a wife, But my daughter’s my daughter all her life.

  —Dinah Maria Mulock Craik (1826–1887), Young and Old

  Contents

  Cover

  Other Books by This Author

  Title Page

  Copyright

  Dedication

  Epigraph

  Prologue

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Prologue

  Twenty Years Ago

  “I have the papers.” The woman named Mrs. DelBello was gently rounded and looked starched, although she was not a nurse. “Do you want to read them? I can give you a few minutes.”

  The other woman seemed unsure. “I suppose I should.” She pulled herself up carefully to a sitting position in the hospital bed, wincing slightly, then adjusted the pillow behind her. Sunlight streamed through the single window, exactly hitting the papers on her lap. She looked toward the window, but could see nothing except sky. They were on a high floor, the tallest building in the area. “Just give me a few minutes.”

  Mrs. DelBello walked quietly out of the room and the woman in the hospital bed pressed the bridge of her glasses closer to her face and read through the document. It was just as it had been explained to her and she had no problems and no complaints. She looked around for a pen but there was none on the table next to her.

  A moment later Mrs. DelBello knocked lightly, then opened the door, as though, with experience, she had timed the reading of the document. “Do you have any questions, dear?” she asked.

  “I just need a pen.”

  Mrs. DelBello handed her one from her handbag. “I can witness your signature.”

  “Thank you.”

  “Would you like to see her again?”

  The woman in the bed swallowed, closed her eyes for a moment, then shook her head. “No, thank you.”

  “Then I think we’ve done it.”

  “The records are sealed, is that right?” She knew the answer but she wanted to hear it one more time. It was the most important question she had asked.

  “Sealed forever. None of this will go further than the agency. You can rest assured. And they’re a lovely couple. They’ll bring her up just the way you would.”

  “Here’s the agreement.”

  “Thank you. Take it easy, dear. Things will get better.”

  The woman in the bed nodded and watched Mrs. DelBello leave the room for the last time. Then she looked at the window again, at the sky and the brilliant light. It was time to rest, to rest assured.

  1

  A small crowd had gathered down the block and across the street from my house when I came outside that afternoon with Eddie, my two-and-a-half-year-old. I knew before I got there what it was about, a situation I had shaken my head over more than once during the spring months, wondering at the things that people found to argue over. It would be better not to walk in that direction and get caught in the fracas but Eddie spotted my friend watching from her driveway and said, “Mel. Wanna see Mel,” as he took off toward his chief cookie-baker-and-giver and the small angry crowd nearby.

  They were actually shouting when we got there.

  “Chris, hi,” Mel said, scooping up Eddie. “I know what you want.”

  “A cookie.” He said it with the kind of smile Mel found irresistible.

  “We’ll get you a cookie soon,” she said, nuzzling him so that he giggled. “They’re going to kill each other over this,” she said to me. “Can you believe it’s gone this far?”

  “Only when I see it.”

  “Yes, you will,” the man at the center of the group was saying in too loud a voice. “And you’ll pay for it. You’ve had ten years to take care of this and you haven’t done a damn thing.”

  “You have no heart,” the woman standing nearest him called back. “That’s all I can say. You probably drown stray cats, too.”

  “Enough,” Mel said. “Let’s go inside and find the cookies and get away from this horror. I hate seeing reasonable people become monsters.” She looked around. “Sari? Noah? Come on. We’re going in.”

  The five of us trooped into the house, the children grabbing their cookies and going upstairs, Mel and I hanging around the kitchen until the tea was made and then carrying our snack into the family room.

  “Hal talked about moving last night,” Mel said after she poured.

  “Mel, don’t say that. What will I do without you?”

  “What will I do? But this is getting crazy. That man has lost his mind and the Greiners won’t give an inch. He’s probably got the law on his side and I understand his point of view, but it’s hard to like him. The Greiners are nice people but they’ve got to acknowledge they’ve caus
ed a problem for him. Did you get the flyer in your mailbox?”

  “Two flyers. One for and one against. Jack checked with the police, just on a hunch. Do you know Mr. Kovak owns a handgun?”

  “What?”

  “A pistol. It’s all licensed and legal. He doesn’t have a permit to carry, just to keep it on the premises.”

  “That’s very scary.”

  “Lots of people own guns, Mel. It’s the world we live in.”

  “Well, he better not use it over a tree.”

  It was a tree, in fact, that was the center of the discord on Pine Brook Road, a tree that had turned neighbor against neighbor. However many years ago, a seed from a silver maple had blown from the mother tree and settled on the edge of the Greiners’ property, eventually planting itself and becoming a small sapling. I had not lived in Oakwood when that happened, although I had visited my aunt frequently in the house that I inherited from her a few years ago. When the seed rooted, I was a Franciscan nun living upstate in St. Stephen’s Convent, not far from the Hudson River. By the time Aunt Meg had died, bequeathing the house to me, and I had been released from my vows and taken up residence on Pine Brook Road, the once tiny and fragile sapling was already a tree. Today, four years later, it was a good-sized tree with pretty, silvery leaves that moved gracefully in the wind and shaded the area beneath, and unfortunately wreaked havoc with Mr. Kovak’s driveway only a few feet away from the trunk and just above the most aggressive of the roots.

  The upshot of this natural phenomenon was that the Kovaks’ driveway, an expensive concrete job, was being raised by the thickening roots. During the winter he had quite a problem getting over the icy hump and he was not happy. His anger had blossomed with the first green leaves of spring. I couldn’t blame him. What he wanted from the Greiners was the removal of the tree, the removal of all the roots, and the replacement of the damaged piece of his driveway. The Greiners would have none of it.

  “The Greiners could have mowed it down ten years ago when it was a flexible stick with a leaf,” I said. “I hate to tell you what Jack mows down by accident.”

  “He’s not the only one.” Mel sipped her tea. “You’re right. They could have. I’m sure they went to some trouble to preserve it when they saw it. And they should have known it wouldn’t stay tiny for long. I mean, if you plant things, you know they’re going to grow.”

  “How did the Kovaks’ driveway come to be so close to the property line?” I asked. “The law says you have to leave so many feet between the boundary and whatever you build.”

  “I heard they got a variance when they built the house because the property was a little smaller than the usual minimum. It just worked out that way and the town gave them the variance because if they didn’t, they wouldn’t build a house there and the town wouldn’t get the taxes and—you see the way they were thinking. The Kovaks have the law on their side.”

  “But such anger,” I said. “Such hostility. Can’t the Greiners agree to anything?”

  “What’s to agree to? If they don’t get rid of the tree, the problem will only get worse. Someone even suggested the Kovaks try to move the driveway closer to their house but that’s a tremendous expense and who’s to say the tree won’t send its roots over that way?”

  “I hate the way people are taking sides. They need some kind of professional mediator.”

  “Why don’t you volunteer?” Mel gave me a smile. “You got this town out of a hole a couple of years ago.”

  She was referring to the time when, soon after I had moved in, I was appointed to determine who had murdered a woman in Brooklyn forty years earlier. “I’m not exactly disinterested,” I said. “Although to the extent that I can’t side with either of them, I guess I am.”

  “I just hate the bickering,” Mel said. “It seems to me, setting aside which neighbor I like and which one I don’t like, that the Greiners should cut the tree down and see if they can negotiate some kind of settlement with the Kovaks. Maybe if they offer to pay half the cost of fixing the driveway, the Kovaks will come around.”

  It sounded reasonable to me, although I could see that the Kovaks might want full restitution and if they took the case to court, they might get it. “Is there a lawsuit yet?” I asked.

  “I don’t really know. I’m sure there will be if this isn’t settled. If that tree keeps on growing this summer the way it’s been growing the last few years, that driveway’s going to be a mess when winter comes. I don’t know. Mr. Kovak is not a pleasant person but I think he’s right in this case.”

  “I don’t know him very well,” I said. “What’s unpleasant about him?”

  “He just seems to be mad at the world. I’ve said hello to him when I was walking or jogging past the house and he was working outside, and he’s practically turned his back on me. Maybe he’s had a tough life; I don’t know. But it sure looks like this tree is the last straw.”

  We changed the conversation at that point and when I finally dragged Eddie down from the second floor and went outside, the angry crowd had completely disappeared. I walked the length of the Greiners’ property—they were Mel’s next-door neighbors—and stood near what appeared to be the property line and looked at the offending tree. It was very pretty, tall and slim, its silvery leaves a pleasure to watch in the breeze. Almost next to it, the driveway had heaved and I could sympathize with anyone who had to drive over it, especially in the winter.

  “What’re you looking at?” an angry voice asked, and Eddie grabbed my leg and stood close to me.

  “The tree and the driveway,” I said, trying to exhibit fairness.

  “Well, there’s nothing to look at. Move on.”

  I was standing in the street—our block has no sidewalks—and he had no right to ask me to get off town property, but I had no wish to agitate him. “Come on, Eddie,” I said, taking his hand. “It’s time to go home.”

  “Is that man mad?” Eddie said.

  “I think he’s having a bad day, sweetie. He’s not mad at us. He’s just upset about something.”

  Eddie dropped my hand and picked up a little stone that lay on the road. He showed it to me with pride and I watched him carefully to make sure it didn’t make its way into his mouth. When we got home, he put it down and I got rid of it. Sometimes there are simple solutions to small problems.

  Jack, my husband of almost four years, is a cop. When I met him, not long after I left St. Stephen’s Convent, he was a detective sergeant with NYPD and he was starting law school. Happily, he not only survived law school—no small feat; he was working full-time and going to school at night—but graduated about a year ago, at which time his career changed dramatically. He left the precinct in Brooklyn where he had worked for several years. For many months after graduating and while studying for the bar, he worked at One Police Plaza, the headquarters building in Manhattan, answering telephone questions from police officers in the field, giving them guidance according to the law when they needed it. Since passing the bar a few months ago, an event that prompted a great celebration in our household, his job has changed yet again. He’s still with the Legal Bureau at One PP but now he reads reports concerning unusual police activity called UF 49s, for Uniformed Force, to determine whether the officers involved acted legally. Sometimes these involve shootings or other serious violence, while others are simply police-citizen interactions resulting in complaints of one kind or another.

  I am very happy that he is getting this kind of experience. Neither of us knows where he will go from here, whether he will stay with NYPD or go into the practice of law, but everything he learns now will help him make the right decision and make him a better lawyer, wherever he works.

  On that day of the tree incident, he was working the ten-to-six shift so I was expecting to eat dinner with him when he got home, probably after Eddie went to bed. I got Eddie’s dinner ready and sat with him while he ate. Afterward, I gave him a much needed bath and got him into his pajamas. We were walking back to his bedroom when I he
ard the doorbell ring.

  It was an unusual time for someone to be coming to the door. We don’t get many door-to-door salesmen in Oakwood because there are rigorously enforced rules as to who may engage in such selling. And since this was the dinner hour, it would be odd for a neighbor to drop by without telephoning first. I called down the stairs and went down slowly with Eddie.

  Before I got to the door, the bell rang again. I pulled the door open and was startled by the person standing in front of me. I had never seen her face before but I recognized what she was wearing. It was the brown habit of a novice at St. Stephen’s. The face framed by the veil was young and pale and perhaps just a little frightened.

  “Are you Chris?” she asked.

  “Yes.”

  “I’m Tina. I’m a novice at St. Stephen’s. I need your help.”

  There was a frantic edge to her voice that troubled me. “Come in,” I said. “This is my son, Eddie. Eddie, this is Tina.”

  Eddie smiled. Tina looked at him and smiled, too. “He’s adorable,” she said. “Hi, Eddie.”

  “Hi.”

  “Eddie’s getting ready for bed now,” I said. “Could you give us about ten minutes?”

  “Yes.”

  “You can sit in the family room.” She dropped a stuffed duffel bag on the floor near the door and I led her there, walking through the kitchen to the back of the house. “You can watch TV or read. There are magazines and newspapers.”

  “Thank you.” She sat at one end of the sofa, her spine very straight, and closed her eyes.

  “I’ll be down soon.” I picked up Eddie and took him upstairs, wondering what on earth this was all about. There had been no car parked in front of my house and where we live, if you don’t come by car, you just don’t get here. I could not believe that this girl had walked from a bus or train station.

  I read Eddie a story and put him in his crib. He was starting to get big for the crib but he still fit and I was happy to leave things as they were for a little while longer. He turned over and I covered him with a light blanket. “Good night, sweetie pie,” I said.